Yang Ban Xi, The Eight Model Works. Dir. Yan Ting Yuen. Perf. Xue Qinghua [薛箐华], Tong Xiangling [童祥苓]. Scarabees Film Production: 2005.

I first saw this at the Golden Horse Film Fest amongst a crowd that chuckled both knowingly and nervously all throughout the film. I've been curious for a long time about what prompts that laughter, that inevitable feeling of staginess, corniness, datedness, etc. that affects one as they watch these relics of a bygone era. Why do we laugh, why can't we help but mock the cultural products of that era, when historians, authors of scar literature, etc., didn't make it seem possible to laugh and poke fun back then?


One of my favorite quotes in the film comes from an artist who grew up during the Cultural Revolution Era:
当时,很高兴 [去看那些样板戏]。都很喜欢,特别是红色娘子军。因为他们穿得很少。穿得比较少。有大腿。那些斯宾有退漏在外面。 我们小时候最早的,对异性的那一个欲望是从样板戏开始的。 救灾革命里面发现了有一些真正的有生命的东西。
His testimony is meant to elicit a laugh, but it's laughter in recognition of some wry truth. Overall, this documentary is a relatively light-hearted reflection, one that respectfully treats memories as
memories and focuses instead on the present that has been created
from the past. This structure contrasts to some of the more emotional and ideologically heavy documentaries that
reflect on the period, often with this agonized question of
Why?? hanging overhead. Nevertheless, the director has her (?) own revisionist agenda, as well. Instead of harping on the aesthetic limitations of the Cultural Revolution era model operas, she takes seriously the manner in which these films
had to influence Chinese art, and tries to reframe that in a positive manner. Thus, for the most part, her interviewees seem quite grateful for their participation in these Cultural Revoluton Era model works. They were stars that benefited in the long run, or children who were grateful to have
something to call their own, this stuff that was the irreplacable content of their memories.
Shying away from Beijing-centrism or political anaysis, the director focuses on music, art, and dance in Shanghai. Quite audaciously, the narration even assumes the ghost of Jiang Qing at times. Through fictionalized reminiscence, Jiang Qing laments how her reputation has been so terribly sullied, how nobody recognizes
her vision of Communist art, and how she may have easily been purged but her influence lives on. The director's goal is to trace that influence in modern contemporary art, rock and roll music, hip-hop and "street" dance, and so forth. The documentary concludes with a revival show of
The Red Detachment of Women, staged with the original ballet dancers in Shanghai.


I really liked the modern day street dance interludes. Maybe I'll come back to explain why and clean up this entry, later.